How to Write a Better Bad Guy | NY Book Editors
‹ Back to blog

Unraveling the Psychology of the “Bad Guy”

FEATURED IMAGE New York Book Editors 12 11 23 Unraveling the Psychology of the Bad Guy

Have you ever found yourself fascinated by the “bad guy” in a story? Is it the story’s antagonist, not the hero, who lingers in your mind long after reading? If so, you're in the right place.

In this guide, we're analyzing the story’s antagonists, particularly how and why they work.

Why is studying and deconstructing the bad guy important?

We focus a lot on the main character, but the antagonist is just as vital to the story. A well-developed antagonist adds layers of conflict and tension. When written correctly, the antagonist is the key to a compelling read.

But how do you transform your antagonist from an obstacle to a character who resonates with the reader? How do you craft a villain that’s not just a foil for the hero but a fully realized individual with unique fears, desires, and motivations? That’s what we’re about to explore. Let’s get started.

What Makes for a Compelling Antagonist?

When you think of an antagonist, you might picture a villain plotting in a dimly lit room with a sinister laugh. But there's so much more to this pivotal character. An antagonist is the force that opposes your protagonist, i.e., your main character. They represent the mountain your hero must climb. The antagonist is not always evil. Sometimes, the antagonist is merely at odds with your main character's goals.

How to Write a Better Bad Guy

Why a Strong Antagonist Matters

Imagine a story where the protagonist easily achieves their goal without any hurdles. These stories are dull. That's why you need an antagonist. An antagonist creates conflict, raises stakes, and pushes your protagonist to grow. They directly or indirectly challenge your hero to overcome fears, make tough decisions, and ultimately, transform. A well-crafted antagonist adds depth and tension.

And an antagonist is always present in the most beloved stories. Think about some of the best stories you've ever read. What made them stick with you? I’m willing to bet there’s a fascinating antagonist present. Take Voldemort in “Harry Potter.” Voldemort’s dark past and complex relationship with Harry enriches the narrative. Or consider the nuanced portrayal of the creature in Mary Shelley's “Frankenstein.” This story challenges the reader’s assumption of who the real monster is. Great antagonists always provoke great questions.

As you begin to craft your story, think deeply about your antagonist. They should be as rich and multi-dimensional as your protagonist. Ask yourself:

  • What are their motivations?

  • What drives them to oppose the protagonist?

  • How do their actions affect the story’s trajectory?

Remember, your antagonist is not just a hurdle for your protagonist—they're a mirror. The antagonist’s job is to reflect your story's themes and moral questions.

The Psychology of Antagonism

How can you use psychology to craft an antagonist who is not just a roadblock but a multi-dimensional character that readers can understand and even sympathize with?

First, remember that we’re not just creating a bad guy. We’re building a psychologically rich character whose humanity resonates with readers. To craft such a character, you must see your antagonist as a fully realized person with their own goals and morality. And that starts by knowing what makes your antagonist who they are.

This is why you need a well-developed antagonist: Your antagonist adds depth and tension to your story.

Peeking into the Mind of Your Antagonist

Psychology is the key to unlocking character depth. Think of your antagonist as a puzzle. Each psychological trait is a piece that, when put together, reveals a complete, compelling picture. Are they driven by fear, a thirst for power, or a twisted sense of justice? Understanding these motivations is crucial for creating an authentic and impactful character.

Here are two popular psychological theories to inspire your antagonist's character development:

  • Freud’s Theory of Personality - Consider how the Id, Ego, and Superego might manifest in your antagonist. Maybe they're driven by primal desires (Id) or trapped in a constant struggle between their moral compass and darker impulses.

  • Jung’s Archetypes - Is your antagonist a 'Shadow'? In other words, do they embody the repressed qualities of the protagonist? Or maybe the antagonist is a 'Trickster' who challenges norms and creates chaos?

Here are a couple of common psychological traits that you can explore in your antagonist:

  • Narcissism - Does your antagonist have an inflated sense of self-importance?

  • Machiavellianism - Are they cunning and manipulative? Do they value power over ethics?

  • Psychopathy - Does your antagonist lack empathy and remorse? Are they prone to impulsive and risky behavior? Are they calculating?

By seeing your antagonist not just as a “bad guy” but as a complex individual with unique motivations and moral compass, you create a character that feels more relatable to your readers.

How to Craft a Multi-Dimensional Antagonist

One-dimensional bad guys are so last century. Your readers crave complexity. So, let’s add some shades of grey.

The Art of Humanizing Your Antagonist

Your antagonist is the protagonist in their own story. Creating a relatable antagonist is about finding the human behind the menace. Here’s how to do that effectively.

  • Give Them Relatable Motives - Maybe they’re fighting for something they genuinely believe in, or past traumas shape them. Their actions, however extreme, should stem from recognizable human desires and fears.

  • Craft a Compelling Backstory - What led them to this point? A powerful backstory can make even the most heinous actions understandable, if not justifiable.

  • Show Their Vulnerabilities - Everyone has weaknesses, fears, and insecurities. Expose these softer sides to create empathy and add depth to your antagonist.

  • See the World Through Their Eyes - Shift the lens and view the world from your antagonist’s perspective. For example, answer these questions:
    • How do they justify their actions to themselves? What's their logic?

    • Are they torn between their desires and moral dilemmas?

    • How do they relate to other characters?

Consider a few well-crafted antagonists in literature who are more than just villains. One example is Cersei Lannister in “Game of Thrones.” Her love for her children and her past experiences shape her ruthless actions. Or consider Magneto from the X-Men comics, whose traumatic past and desire to protect his kind make his extreme methods relatable.

How to Write a Better Bad Guy

Adding Psychological Depth to Your Antagonist

Now that we've learned how to humanize your antagonist, let's add more depth to them. To do that, we’ll need to start with their psychology. A complex web of psychological factors shapes your antagonist’s actions and thoughts.

Consider how certain psychological traits or disorders could inform your antagonist’s actions. But avoid stereotypes. If you choose to give your antagonist a specific disorder, research thoroughly to portray it accurately and sensitively.

Also, remember to mix negative traits with positive or, at least, understandable ones. Maybe your antagonist is incredibly loyal to their cause or shows unexpected kindness. Showing this side of your antagonist is a great way to create conflict in your readers’ minds.

Speaking of conflict, explore the antagonist’s internal and external conflicts at length (even if only for your character development research). Write detailed sketches exploring your antagonist’s psychological makeup. Internal conflicts (like guilt, fear, or self-doubt) and external conflicts (like societal pressures or confrontations with the protagonist) drive the antagonist’s actions and decisions.

It's easy to fall into the trap of mad scientist or evil genius tropes. Strive for authenticity. Portray them as a whole person rather than define them by their antagonism or mental health.

Practical Exercises for Writing the “Bad Guy”

Ready to write a whole antagonist? Let’s roll up our sleeves and get started with a few practical exercises that will bring your antagonist to life and sharpen your storytelling skills.

Writing Prompts and Exercises

  • Antagonist's Diary - Write diary entries from your antagonist's perspective. What do they fear? What do they want more than anything? This exercise helps you get inside their head.

  • Alternate Reality - Write a scene where your antagonist is the protagonist. How does this shift in perspective change your view of their actions and motivations?

  • Dialogue Duel - Craft a conversation between your antagonist and another character that reveals the antagonist’s motivations. Focus on subtext and what's left unsaid.

  • Psychology Crash Course - Spend time learning basic psychological concepts. Websites like Psychology Today can offer insights into human behavior and motivations.

  • Character Case Studies - Analyze antagonists from your favorite books or movies. What psychological traits do they display? How do these traits influence their actions?

Final Thoughts

You're now ready to create a compelling, psychologically rich antagonist. Remember, a great antagonist can elevate your entire narrative. They provide depth and tension that keep readers engaged. Your antagonist is just as crucial to your story as your protagonist. Together, these characters shape the plot and make for a memorable story.

You might also like...
What’s the most effective way to work with literary agents? In this guide, we share need-to-know best practices for work...
Read More
Here are our top tips on pricing, distributing, and marketing your book. This is part 3 of our series for self-published...
Read More
Would you like to settle the point of view debate once and for all? Check out this post on perspectives, and figure out ...
Read More